X
Story Stream
recent articles

For over two years the former Fairmount Temple building in Beachwood, Ohio, has stood empty. This beautiful structure was the work of Percival Goodman (1904-1989), a respected city planner and Columbia University architecture professor who designed over fifty synagogues, along with a couple of churches, some public schools and parts of the Queensborough Community College and other projects.

Repurposed synagogue buildings designed by Goodman are now early learning centers, a public school, businesses, churches, mosques, a Hindu temple, a Boston College site, and a YMCA outreach center.  These buildings remain loved for their artistry, durability, flexible plans, and pleasant, uplifting effect on the public.

When completed in 1957, the Fairmount Temple building (which since had at least two additions) was known for offering the most square feet on one floor of any religious building.  Alanna Cooper, a professor at Case Western Reserve University, recently paid moving tribute to that building.

The Jewish congregation that built it, the first in Cleveland, was down to half of its peak number of families, and decided to merge with an equally-sized congregation with a similar decline in membership, with hopes of pooling combined numbers and resources. But instead of ensuring that the property be acquired by another religious organization, whether Jewish or of another faith, the leadership opted to sell the building in 2024 to the City of Beachwood. The understanding was that the city would demolish it in order to develop the property so as to recoup and surpass its expenditures on the land with perpetual tax revenues.

The city officials held public forums and were clearly hoping that the property would be used for senior housing. Their strategy was that large Beachwood homes currently held onto by elderly owners would be sold to young families, bringing more tax money to the city and more children to its public schools. A developer (actually, a consortium of developers) expressed interest in the project, relieving the City Council of having to themselves undertake a demolition that would be painful to many citizens, and enabling them to secure tax revenues from what had been a vast tax-exempt zone.

But in September, the deal fell through, and the city officials decided instantly that their immediate goal was to tear down the building and to leave the development of the land for a more opportune time or deal. A 2023 electrical fire near the sanctuary wing had left visible singe marks and the need for significant repairs. Such repairs will not be cheap (nothing is, including new construction), but the building is in decent shape, and was obviously deemed structurally sound enough to have been left standing for two years.

At an October 5 meeting of the Beachwood City Council, the long ago fire along with asbestos and other concerns were invoked as reason to declare the building “blighted” property. The vote carried for the “blighted” designation. As of now, however, the building still stands.

The most dramatic Beachwood City Council meeting was held on October 19. Several thoughtful and articulate townspeople stated their opposition to city officials’ desire to accede to the Cuyahoga County’s wish to build a new library building on the site of the former Fairmount Early Childhood Center, on the same street and close to the temple property. They noted that this project would require expensive removal of scores of trees, leveling hills, and traffic expansion. They presented their concerns about destruction of natural resources, changes in traffic patterns that could endanger children on bicycles, and dictation by the County, which operates the public libraries in this and other cities, of public building locations to local communities.

A lifelong admirer of Goodman and his work, I entered, several months ago, into correspondence with Beachwood city officials, who kindly allowed me to visit the site again after many years. I also spoke to Cuyahoga County officials when I first read of their plans to expand the current library and hoped that they might consider preserving parts of the Fairmount Temple building which had put Beachwood on the map in journals of modern architecture and religious art.

During my first discussions with Beachwood and county library officials I was told that they wanted the Beachwood branch to remain where it was, on land that borders a middle school, so that the students there would continue to have convenient access to it. It seemed strange to me that the county would favor and prioritize one local school in its long range library plans, so I floated the idea of utilizing the temple wings along Fairmount Boulevard as a library branch, along with other thoughts.

I was glad to learn that others had made the library suggestion as well. I could not, and still cannot, understand why that proposal was not considered in more detail.

In time the county deemed the current library location abutting the middle school inadequate. The library planners want an auditorium, a larger lot, and more space. And now that many Beachwood citizens have raised their voices against utilizing the county’s current preferred venue, the Fairmount Temple property will be, or at least should be, in the minds of their politicians. The choice would then be either to demolish the Goodman building and to start from scratch, or to utilize parts of it and to find some taxable uses for the rest of the land. Will the Beachwood officials rush the demolition to eliminate that choice and that conversation?

As it happens, the parts of the Goodman building that front Fairmount Boulevard include a high-ceilinged sanctuary/social hall wing that can be divided into upper and lower levels, a good-sized open chapel/lounge area, multiple offices, a vast lobby, and a large atrium that filled in an original outdoor courtyard — all of which can be engagingly reconfigured and augmented by creative architects. There is also a large theater auditorium along the parking lot that was designated by the ahead-of-its-time congregation as a gathering place reserved for young families. In recent years it had been used successfully by a local orchestra and for other performances.

Those parts of the building contain creative and artistic flourishes that will be lost — olive motifs (symbolic of the hope for peace) on well-crafted doors and chapel walls, for example, and, especially, murals by Abraham Rattner on entry pillars.

Most ingenious of all are the clerestory sanctuary windows which illumine the interior with a spectrum of pastel colors without use of stained glass. Goodman was proud that painting the louvred window frames provided abundant color without sacrificing clear glass. That effect could still prove engaging in library rooms.

Demolition of the expansive school wings (the size of some large public schools) and utilization of the rest of the seventeen acres could still provide space for ample parking and for townhouses that could generate taxable income.

After the October 19 city council meeting, Cuyahoga County officials wisely and respectfully decided to reconsider some of the controversial aspects of their plans for the Early Childhood Center property. Could that property now be reconfigured for some private housing, preserving the trees and hills and ballparks as well?

There is an opportunity here for integrating city planning, architectural preservation, combined tax-generating and city-county cooperative spaces, and even creative fundraising. Would community members, both Jewish or of other faiths, with some attachment to the building or to the creativity of such a project, make donations to the cause? Are there resourceful foundations in the area or elsewhere that would be moved to help? Would the landmarking of parts of the Fairmount Temple building enable the city and county to benefit from other funds? Other foundations might be particularly interested in preserving the Rattner murals which might serve as a unique historical marker to memorialize the congregation and its visionary leaders who built a structure that introduced unprecedented forms of synagogue architecture and art.

Architect Percival Goodman was a pioneer in mid-century urban planning and environmentalism. His book, Communitas (1947), written with his brother Paul Goodman, well-respected social critic, dealt expressly and foresightedly with creative integration and configuration of construction and natural resources, and his later book, The Double E (1977), was a pioneering call to environmentalism. In the latter book, he suggested that not taking down buildings could be a cornerstone of prudent environmentalism and community building.

A lot of outstanding, architecturally fine mid-century (and earlier) synagogues and churches will be in danger of the wrecking ball unless repurposed by creative cities and counties. Hopefully, civic governments and organizations will rise to the challenge of working with private individuals and foundations for imaginative architectural preservation.

Rabbi Elliot B. Gertel is the Rabbi Emeritus of Congregation Rodfei Zedek in Chicago. He has been film and television reviewer of the "National Jewish Post and Opinion" since 1979. His books include What Jews Know About Salvation and Over the Top Judaism: Precedents and Trends in the Depiction of Jewish Beliefs and Observances in Film and Television.

Comment
Show comments Hide Comments